- MarketMunch
- Posts
- đź›’ Is Instacart A Buy?
đź›’ Is Instacart A Buy?
PLUS: The math on a $7 scanner

The Math On a $7 Scanner
Here's the math on my Black Friday deal. $7, one payment, a full year of the Instant Scanner. There are roughly 250 trading nights in a year. That's 2.8 cents a night to have nearly a thousand of America's biggest stocks checked for you, with exact buy prices on whatever qualifies. At $7, the money isn't the question anymore. It's just whether you get around to it.
👉 Take the $7 deal >>

đź›’ Why Instacart Trades Below Offer
Here’s a head-scratcher sitting in plain sight. DoorDash $DASH agreed to buy grocery-delivery company Instacart $CART for $65.00 a share, yet Instacart’s stock closed at just $58.48 on November 12, about 10% below that price. When a stock trades below an agreed buyout price like that, it’s the market quietly saying it’s not fully convinced the deal will cross the finish line.
That price was a 26% premium, meaning DoorDash offered well above where Instacart was trading before the deal. So why would investors leave 10% on the table instead of grabbing a sure thing? Because this deal is far from a sure thing. Let’s break down the doubt.
The timeline is long
Part of the gap is simply time. DoorDash doesn’t expect the deal to close until around the end of 2027 or the first half of 2028. That’s years away, and a dollar promised years from now is worth less than a dollar in hand. Investors aren’t going to pay full price now to wait that long for the payout.
The regulators are circling

The scarier part is antitrust, which is the government’s power to block deals that hurt competition. According to third-party estimates from YipitData, DoorDash already handled about 65% of US delivery-app orders in 2025, while Instacart had around 9%. The FTC, the agency that polices this, is laser-focused on affordability right now, and on the very day the deal was announced it launched a study into how companies like DoorDash and Instacart use shopper data to set prices and wages. DoorDash clearly knows the risk is real, since it agreed to pay Instacart a $1.25 billion fee if regulators block the deal.
Both sides are healthy
This isn’t two sinking ships lashing together, either. Last quarter DoorDash grew revenue 34% while Instacart grew 17%, so both businesses are doing fine on their own. The appeal for DoorDash is clear: Instacart hands it the lead in groceries, a massive everyday market, plus software it sells to grocery stores.
⚖️ The fees cut both ways. DoorDash owes $1.25 billion if regulators sink the deal, while Instacart owes $650 million if it walks for a better offer.
📉 The stocks split. DoorDash is down 23.8% this year and sits about 27.2% below its August 26 closing high, while Instacart is up 30.0%.
🎯 Instacart is near its own peak. Even trading below the offer, the stock sits just 3.9% under its October 26 closing high.
đź‘€ Bonus Report: Hedge Fund guy practically giving away his indicator (via Base Camp Trading)
The Munch Take: My wife uses one app for restaurant takeout and a totally different one for groceries, and she grumbled that it’d be nice if they were just the same app, which is pretty much the entire pitch for this merger in one sentence. The problem is that regulators might look at one giant delivery app getting bigger and decide that’s a bad deal for shoppers, since DoorDash already runs most of the market. So we’re passing on betting the deal through here. The 10% gap below the offer isn’t free money, it’s the market pricing in real odds this gets blocked or dragged out for years, and we don’t like staking cash on a government decision nobody can predict. Both businesses are healthy, which is the good news, but “will the FTC allow it” is a coin flip we’d rather watch than play. When the whole trade hinges on politics, patience beats gambling.
From Tradewins: Others Paid Nearly $2,000. Black Friday Price: $7.
Beat the Crowd: Get Real-Time Market Triggers
Email is great, but the financial markets move at the speed of light. By the time an urgent stock catalyst hits your inbox, the biggest price moves are often already over. Join our priority mobile broadcast to receive instant, bite-sized text notifications on major breaking updates, unexpected earnings beats, and massive institutional volume spikes, long before the rest of the market catches on.
What do you think of today's edition? |
Ads in this email are sent on behalf of Profits Run. MarketMunch receives compensation for these placements. We do not endorse or recommend any specific investments. Please do your own research.
Disclaimer: AlphaMunch and MarketMunch are financial publishing brands owned and operated by Lark Dashboards Inc. All content provided in this newsletter, including single-stock spotlights, market commentary, metrics, and technical analysis, is strictly for informational, educational, and entertainment purposes only and does not constitute personalized financial, legal, tax, or investment advice.
Not a Registered Advisor: Neither Lark Dashboards Inc. nor MarketMunch is a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, or financial planner with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), FINRA, or any other financial regulatory authority.
Risk Warning & Accuracy: Investing in securities, options, and financial markets involves a high degree of risk, including the potential loss of your entire principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. MarketMunch does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of any third-party data presented. Readers are strongly urged to conduct their own independent due diligence and consult with a licensed financial professional before making any investment decisions.
Affiliate & Advertising Disclosure: This publication is supported by advertising. MarketMunch frequently receives financial compensation (including flat placement fees, affiliate clicks, or revenue-share commissions) from third-party advertisers and corporate partners featured in this email. In no event shall Lark Dashboards Inc. or its officers be liable for any direct, indirect, or consequential losses arising from the use of this content or third-party links.
If you have questions or concerns about your subscription, feel free to contact our Canadian-based support team at [email protected].